More Bywords — A Closer Reading

  17   1
Yonge, Charlotte M. (Charlotte Mary), 1823-1901 Project Gutenberg 2004
Poetry; Short stories Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words: 62,306
Reading time: 271 min
Text sections: 6
Charlotte M. Yonge's collection of short stories and poems, including 'The Price of Blood' set in early Christian Gaul and a seaside tale of youthful gambling with chocolate creams, exploring contrasts between sacred and mundane, discipline and indulgence.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.7/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

Edition quality

In 'The Price of Blood,' the opening procession for the Rogation Days in Claudiodunum presents a meticulously observed social hierarchy: children sorted by ancestry ('Ethiopian or Moorish slave ancestry,' 'Roman,' 'Cymric Kelt,' 'Gael'), men distinguished by dress (Gallic trousers versus Roman tunic), and women by color and veil. The litany 'Libera nos, Domine' echoes off the Auvergne rocks, yet the narrator notes that discord is only 'unheard' from a distance—a hint that harmony is fragile.

Later, a seaside episode pivots sharply from sacred to trivial: a 'racing game' with chocolate-cream bets provokes Jane's horror, her father's amused tolerance, and Margaret's reflection that 'children's loyalty run into intolerance and rudeness.' The contrast between the solemn litany and the bathos of chocolate creams underscores Yonge's recurring interest in how small moral lapses mirror larger ones.

Sacred Procession, Social Stratification

The Rogation Day procession in 'The Price of Blood' is a moving tableau of Gaulish society under the late Roman Empire. Yonge devotes careful description to the children's 'motley collection of all shades,' linking physical traits to ancestry—'deep olive and the rolling black eye betraying Ethiopian or Moorish slave ancestry,' 'rufous hair and freckled skin the lower grade of Cymric Kelt.' The men's clothing marks status: 'hardy mountaineers still wearing the Gallic trousers and plaid' versus 'artisans and mechanics ... clad in the tunic and cloak that were the later Roman dress.' Women's costume similarly grades from 'bright, dark crimson, or blue' among the poor to 'white or black' for ladies. The clergy wear 'brilliant priestly vestments, heavy with gold and embroidery.' Yet the narrator emphasizes that this visual order is only beautiful 'from a distance'; up close, the boys are marshalled 'with extreme difficulty,' and the response is 'fitfully' heard. Yonge uses the procession to display both the ideal of communal prayer and the underlying disorder of human nature.

Chocolate Creams and Moral Panic

The seaside narrative pivots on a trivial incident: young people playing a 'racing game' with chocolate-cream bets. Jane's reaction is comically disproportionate—she speaks 'as if she were summoning him to snatch her sister from rouge et noir at Monaco.' Her aunt Edith deflates the drama with 'Fearful depravity, my dear.' Yet the episode is not merely comic. Mr. Methuen, the tutor, 'smiled a little' but later agrees the amusement is 'undesirable, as savouring of evil.' Horace, the father, intervenes to prevent 'any more betting.' Margaret, the sensible sister, diagnoses the problem as 'intolerance and rudeness' masquerading as loyalty. The bon-bons themselves become a symbol: Metelill receives 'gilt and painted boxes' from 'foolish lads,' then repurposes them as prizes. The narrator, Emily, notes the 'tone I do not like to hear in a maiden of any degree'—a tone of coquettish refusal. Yonge layers moral commentary onto a scene of everyday holiday folly, showing how small breaches of decorum can expose larger character flaws.

Voice and Perspective: The Observant Narrator

The excerpts are framed by a first-person narrator, Emily, who records events in diary-like entries with precise time stamps ('13, ten A.M.'). Her voice is measured and critical, yet not harsh. She notes Jane's 'whirlwind fashion' and 'tears of wrath,' but also Jane's later candor: 'a little gentleness would have made a difference.' Emily observes the 'obtuseness to courtesy towards strangers' when young people occupy church benches and 'make themselves square' to block others. She reports conversations indirectly, preserving the flavor of speech: 'Oh no! You won’t! Nonsense!' The narrator does not claim omniscience; she admits when she 'laughed a little, it was impossible to help it.' This limited, personal viewpoint gives the moral reflections a grounded, experiential quality. Yonge uses Emily to filter events through a consciousness that is both engaged and evaluative, allowing the reader to see the gap between ideal behavior and actual human weakness.

Readers attentive to Yonge's method will notice how she uses small, concrete details—a litany, a bon-bon box, a church bench—to open larger questions about community, discipline, and the gap between appearance and reality. The two settings, early Christian Gaul and a Victorian seaside resort, are more alike than they first appear: both are communities trying to maintain order against the pull of disorder. The editorial note is not a substitute for the text; it is an invitation to read with an eye for the specific tensions Yonge embeds in everyday life.

Reader reflection

What did you think of this book?

Answer a few questions and save a private reflection on this device.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

Which reading stage best describes you?

2

Did this book hold your interest?

3

Would you pass this book on to a friend?

4

How much effort did this book require?

Related eBooks